Thursday, June 23, 2022
HomeEconomicsGurbanguly Berdimuhamedov’s Economic Legacy – The Diplomat

Gurbanguly Berdimuhamedov’s Economic Legacy – The Diplomat


Gurbanguly Berdimuhamedov became the president of Turkmenistan in February 2007 following the death of the country’s first president, Saparmurat Niyazov. Berdimuhamedov served as president for 15 years, until February 2022 when his son, Serdar, ascended to the presidency. The economy of Turkmenistan grew exponentially during the first part of Berdimuhamedov’s presidency from 2007 to 2014 due to a higher volume of gas exports, as well as record-breaking high gas prices, which helped generate billions of dollars from exports. The country’s economic output has significantly declined since 2015 due to lower prices of natural gas and the discontinuation of gas exports to Russia and Iran. The second part of Berdimuhamedov’s presidency was marked by economic crisis, inflation, and soaring black-market exchange rates.

Macroeconomic Indicators

The nominal GDP of Turkmenistan under the presidency of Berdimuhamedov grew from $12.66 billion in 2007 to $45.23 billion in 2019, according to World Bank figures. GDP growth rates have not been updated on the Bank’s website since 2020 due to a lack of reliable data of adequate quality. GDP growth was uninterrupted from 2007 to 2014, then dropped sharply and recovered only by 2019. 

There are two problems in analyzing the GDP of Turkmenistan. GDP growth in the country was heavily impacted by the growing volume of exports of natural resources (mostly natural gas), which was the primary export of the country (86.3 percent of all exports). Natural gas is an extractive sector and does not require human capital, innovation, or building factories through industrialization, and it does not employ many people. Moreover, with the help of gas revenue, the government spent billions of dollars on unproductive large projects such as the Awaza tourist zone, AIMAG (the Asian Indoor and Martial Arts Games), hotels and monuments, and currently the construction of a new administration center for the Ahal region, as well as construction of the new Ashgabat City. The government reportedly spent around $2 billion on the Awaza project and $10 billion to organize the AIMAG, and currently 2,500 construction projects are underway, which will cost the state budget over $37 billion. Since government spending is included as part of the GDP calculation, such big construction projects have artificially raised the GDP of Turkmenistan without reflecting actually widespread economic growth. The Turkmen online journal Progres.online estimates that government spending accounts for almost half of the annual GDP of the country.

Furthermore, the GDP of Turkmenistan is calculated in the local currency, the manat, and reported in U.S. dollars based on the official exchange rate. Turkmenistan has two parallel exchange rates: the official exchange rate ($1=3.5 manat) and the black market exchange rate ($1=19.5 manat). Therefore, one can assume that the actual GDP of the country might be completely different — and far lower — had it been reported based on the black market exchange rate. 

Enjoying this article? Click here to subscribe for full access. Just $5 a month.

The Good Old Exchange Rate Drama 

The black-market exchange rate is not the product of Berdimuhamedov’s presidency, its advent stretches  back to the era of the first president, Niyazov (also called Turkmenbashy, meaning “The leader of Turkmens”). Selling and buying foreign currencies was forbidden during the Niyazov era starting in 1998 and such restrictions were lifted in the second year of Berdimuhamedov’s presidency in 2008. Albeit with some restrictions on the amount of dollar exchange, the exchange of currencies was largely allowed to all citizens. The exchange rate was set at a fixed rate, first at 2.8 manat/$1, and later at 3.5 manat/$1. As a result, living standards improved in the country thanks to the cheap exchange rate, which helped average citizens afford imported cars, electronics, and other products. 

However, the free exchange of currencies has been severely restricted since 2016 due to the lower number of hard currencies coming into the country, which was a result of declining prices of natural gas and the discontinuation of gas exports to Russia and Iran. Restrictions on the free exchange of currencies paved the way for the rise of yet another black market exchange rate in Turkmenistan but this time under the presidency of Berdimuhamedov. The black market rate reached up to 40 manat/$1 in April 2021, which was 11 times more expensive than the official exchange rate. Then it started to slowly decline and reached around 19.5 manat as of writing, which is still five times more expensive compared to the official exchange rate. 

When it comes to salaries, the 2022 minimum monthly wage in the country is 1,050 manat and the average monthly wage is 2,040 manat. Using the official exchange rate, these figures equal $299.69 and $582.26, respectively; but under the black-market rate they are worth only around $54 and $105. It’s a vast difference.

High Inflation

As a result of the growing black market exchange rate, everything became more expensive, and inflation soared in the country. Turkmenistan has not yet undergone full industrialization and domestic production is too low to meet the demands of consumers. Due to the cheap exchange rate in the first half of Berdimuhamedov’s presidency, the country largely imported the majority of its consumer products.

Although the government does not publicly share any data regarding inflation rates in the country, one can glean information about inflation in Turkmenistan from international organizations, academics, and alternative third-party sources. IMF’s forecasted inflation rate in the country ranges from 6 percent  to 21 percent for the period between 2016 and 2021, while Steve Hanke from John Hopkins University assessed the inflation rate in Turkmenistan from 50 percent in 2017 to 350 percent in mid-2018 and back to 50 percent in 2021. The “Palaw Index” from Progres.online measures monthly inflation in Turkmenistan by tracking the price of ingredients for the famous Turkmen dish palaw such as sunflower oil, beef, onions, carrots, rice, and flour. According to the Palaw Index, year-on-year inflation was 45 percent in January, 20 percent in February and 16 percent in March of 2022. 

Source: Hanke’s Inflation Satellite

Enjoying this article? Click here to subscribe for full access. Just $5 a month.

Conclusion

The beginning of Berdimuhamedov’s presidency was marked by high economic growth caused by high gas prices and larger volumes of exports until 2014. However, instead of investing the extra revenue gained through gas exports in those years toward health, education, and hard infrastructure, the government wasted almost all of the revenue on building monuments, airports, luxury hotels, and the underused Awaza tourist zone, as well as hosting the AIMAG. Despite high growth in the beginning, high inflation and a soaring black-market exchange rate became the legacies of Berdimuhamedov’s time in office. 

RELATED ARTICLES

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular

Recent Comments